November 18, 2026
Episode 26
The LEGO game that broke product data
Live from B2B Online Atlanta, Matt Johnson and Floyd Blaikie sit down with Pivotree colleagues Ryan Smith and Casey Dupuis to share real-world stories from the booth, covering why 45 manufacturer product attributes shrink to five on distributor sites, lessons from a LEGO spec-sheet workshop, why premature AI enrichment sends teams back to step zero, and how post-acquisition tech debt (12 ERPs and six PIM/MDM systems) actively slows down M&A velocity.
Listen to Data vs. Commerce
Watch Data vs. Commerce
Episode 26 - The LEGO game that broke product data
Matt: Welcome to Data vs. Commerce, where we explore the messy middle between database and doorstep. I'm Matt Johnson.
Floyd: And I'm Floyd Blaikie. Let's dig in.
Floyd: Okay, we're back with another event-focused episode. And listen, it is event season, full swing for manufacturers and distributors particularly. Lots of stuff going on, although I think we're starting to wind down. People are retiring their travel bags and maybe getting over the con crud that has been plaguing them for a lot of Q4 so far.
But all four of us were just in Atlanta last week, where we went to B2B Online East, B2B Online Atlanta. And it was a really fun time, and I'm really excited to hear what you folks thought of what we heard on the floor, what we saw in the other booths, and the conversations that we had with manufacturers and distributors.
Of course, unfortunately for us, Casey and Ryan, there was one undisputed star of the show, and that was Mr. Matt Johnson, who I have some very cool photos of giving his TED Talk. So do you want to start there, Matt? What did you talk about in your workshop, and what did you hear from folks when you spoke to them afterwards?
Matt: Yeah. Thanks, Floyd. I feel a little guilty doing back-to-back event episodes, just because I don't want it to be about us, right? Like, that's not the point of this podcast. However, I think there is something really valuable to be said about when we come on and do these post-event episodes.
The idea here is to really give our audience a taste of what other practitioners in the industry are talking about, the pain points that they're bringing up when they talk to consultants like us, and really kind of just the state of the industry. And so yeah, we showed up at B2B Online.
We've been attending there for several years, and we love the community. We love the opportunity to get in front of people that are doing the work, hands on keyboards, or managing those who are doing the work. And so we are hearing a lot of chatter right now about data and data syndication.
And so yeah, the workshop that I hosted was really about the broken telephone game in product data, the digital supply chain, right? So we talked about how raw material becomes a finished product, and then that product moves throughout the supply chain down to a distribution channel or a retailer, and ultimately in the hands of the people that need to have it.
And oof, manufacturers and distributors are masters of the physical supply chain, but when it comes to product data, we see this weird telephone game, right, where translation is being broken down. And so that was what we talked about. And the way that we demonstrated this was... So I didn't wanna just get up on stage and give a talk about this problem.
So you and I, Floyd, did something really fun, which I enjoyed because frankly, when I go to these things, I'm like, "I don't wanna just hear another person ramble." So we did a hands-on activity. I felt like we were in kindergarten again. It was so fun, because we had folks break up into two different groups and this side of the room was the supply chain group, and they sat at a table, and they had to take a look at this finished LEGO product.
So we were playing with LEGO bricks for half of this workshop.
Casey: Matt, as an avid collector of LEGOs, I have a problem with you calling it a kindergarten project, all right?
Floyd: I mean, it really was. We had worksheets, we had building blocks, we had five-minute timers until you had to transition to your next activity. It was basically kindergarten, but...
Matt: Yeah. Or a summer camp vibe, right? So here I am, the counselor leading this activity, this craft. But it was really fun watching the supply chain teams look at the finished product, and what their job was they had to describe the product on a one-page sheet listing out specification and attributes about this product.
And then we took that spec sheet, and we brought it over to the buyer side, and that team had a bunch of just broken pieces, non-put-together pieces or whatever on the table, and their job was to read that spec sheet and build that finished product. And boy, was that fun to watch because you can see the translation problem that happens between a supplier and their buyer, and that highlighted the whole issue that frankly we're talking about, but for good reason because it's the real problem in the B2B e-commerce industry.
Floyd: And it's not a perfect metaphor, right? Because things don't end up unrecognizable when they go through the digital supply chain and lose information. But the picture that data paints is certainly different for the buyer than what the manufacturer or even the distributor intended.
I think the important part was people thought it was fun, right? A lot of these talks can sometimes not be fun. Even my children, who are seven and nine and don't know anything about product data, no matter how many episodes of the podcast I force them to listen to, they got the point and they thought it was very funny.
So I am gonna make sure that we have those photos posted on LinkedIn if you...
Matt: I am glad that you have your kids listening just to get our numbers up. I mean, there's nothing wrong with that.
Floyd: Yeah, you gotta cheese the numbers a little bit, right? It's vanity metrics. That's what we care about.
Casey: I gotta get my kids on here too.
Floyd: Hey, there's an idea. We have a podcast takeover where our kids host and they talk about product data. I don't think you'll learn anything, but it will be very entertaining. Yeah.
Ryan: Be okay if there's LEGO involved.
Floyd: It'll be a LEGO podcast. Exactly. Are we a LEGO podcast now? We might be. So Matt was tearing it up on the stage.
And we gave away some cool LEGO, and that was pretty fun. I was entering my Vanna White era here. I was helping out, ferrying things back and forth and pointing to the pieces of the paper that they needed to fill out. But Ryan, you were busy doing real adult tasks during the workshop times.
I think talking to folks on the floor, going around and talking to other vendors. What were you hearing at B2B Online Atlanta that was, I guess, different from what you've heard at other events this year?
Ryan: Yeah, it was a lot of fun for sure, and it was a shame. I did get to step in for a couple minutes to see a bit of the breakout session, so that was great. And I know Matt said that he didn't want this podcast to be about us, but I'm okay if it's a little bit about me. As sales, I always want people looking in my direction.
So, what I heard, I think at this time of year and in the last few conferences that we've been to, the message has been still a lot of the same, where people all are sort of on that same level now. They understand everything starts with data. Data needs to be governed the right way. The modeling needs to be set up the right way.
A lot of it is around growth, how the company's growing, whether they're growing for geography, growing for adding product lines, and how to inherit that data into the system. I know that for a lot of it, Casey and I were talking about a lot of the companies that were going through mergers and acquisitions, and maybe Casey can touch a little bit more on what he heard around that.
But I would say that for the most part, a lot of the companies were on the same page, that they understood where to start. Some of them had tried some things that didn't work out, whether they be AI tools to enrich or get some lift in a certain part of their process, but because the data, that foundation, wasn't there, they didn't work.
So they're sort of back to step zero, if you will, of getting their priorities in the right order, cleaning the closet, getting started on that journey, and it was nice. We got a lot of follow-up meetings booked with a lot of companies that I'll say I noticed a difference in the companies that came to Atlanta versus in the Midwest.
There were some new companies that I hadn't talked to anyone at their business yet, so it was really nice to lean into those a little bit more and start to understand more about their business and their initiatives going forward. Yeah, but it was a great time overall, and it was fun to have you guys there.
Now, Floyd, this was your first event that you've come with us on. What did you think about our conference?
Floyd: It's true. My first event with Pivotree. Yeah, the last event I went to in a professional capacity was EdTech. Was very different. So I thought it was really neat to hear directly from people on the floor the challenges that they'd had around technology. We heard from someone who was trying to wrangle multiple PIMs.
An awful lot of these manufacturers and distributors are growing by acquisition, and that's not something I've never heard of before. I've worked with a services provider in the industrial space that had 17 instances of Salesforce. One instance of Salesforce is hard enough to manage, let alone 17.
Nothing quite that bonkers at this show. But yeah, it's a real issue is, it's not always a matter of not having enough technology to manage the business. Sometimes it's we have way too much, and we have no idea where to start to make this work for us. We have several systems of record, and the records are incomplete or imperfect, and we have no one system of work, which is a term that I've shamelessly stolen from Matt's workshop.
So it was interesting to hear folks talk about that and realize that sometimes it's not that we don't have enough tools, it's that we have too many tools, and we don't know which one to pick up first, right?
Ryan: Yeah, that's an excellent point.
Floyd: What did you see, Casey? You've been uncharacteristically silent so far. I'm curious, what was your favourite part of the...
Matt: That's because you told him he had to be clean. He wasn't allowed to say any bad words.
Floyd: It's true. We gotta protect our rating.
Matt: Yeah, let's unleash him. Let's go.
Casey: I'm trying to be really good over here, guys, you know? So yeah, there was a couple really great things I liked about this show. Not to get away from the show, but for one, great venue, you know? Like, really nice place that they had it at, and I really appreciate that.
As someone who goes to a decent amount of shows, it's great to go and feel comfortable where you are and kinda settle right in. So that was the first thing. Man, I have a whole new appreciation for spec sheets, I'll tell you that. I think there's a number of people who visited our booth who feel the same, as they realized how challenging it can be to put one of those things together, you know?
They were like, "Oh yeah, I'll jump in there and do it," and then they sat down, they're like, "Oh my, this is overwhelming." So that was cool. One of the things I really liked about this show was there was kind of an intimate factor to it with as people came in, they provided them those cards that they had to get the peaches for.
They were little stickers that they had to put on a sheet. And it created a lot of interaction on the floor, which sometimes you don't always get as a vendor, frankly. But it wasn't fabricated. Like, it was actually really good conversation. It had a lot of people talking to each other and sharing ideas, and I think that really changes the environment, right?
Because not only are they going into these breakout sessions, which are great, super valuable, that's primarily why people are there, but then they can come out and they can share those ideas, and they can talk to vendors and say, "Hey, this is what I'm hearing. This is what you're hearing. This is really great," and it becomes a fostering a lot of learning in that type of environment, which I think is why we go, right?
It's not just about listening to people. It's about sharing ideas. And I guess to get back to what has been said twice, but taking it a little bit further, is, for example, I talked to one company that said they did, like, eight acquisitions a year, and now they're down to three to five, right?
And what they said was, "Hey, it's not that we wanna slow down." They had 12 ERPs. They had six PIM and MDM platforms. And they said, "The challenge we have is the bottleneck of getting the data into our system, being able to get those products to a place where we can bring them to market effectively without worrying about the performance of those in an e-commerce world," right?
So it just really highlighted the disparate silos of information. The fact that, look, I think all of us are being asked to do more these days with less. And that's not an easy thing, right? We're all kind of figuring out technology as it's moving so fast, as well as the asks of our organizations.
And it's exciting, but it doesn't take away the challenges. So I think that was probably the most overwhelming thing I heard, and frankly, I think it pushes us all to get better and to learn together, and that was probably what was most exciting for me.
So, overall, I really enjoyed the show. I thought it was well put together, and I really enjoyed being with this group, and I look forward to it again next year.
Matt: Yeah, we have tons of fun. It's almost crazy that this is our job sometimes. We get to go out there and really enjoy ourselves and enjoy building relationships with the community, the larger community. And it's not about... I mean, of course, we would love to get new clients, and of course, we would love to extend our services with existing customers.
But really what I love about these shows is the ability to learn, right? And to test what we instinctively think are the biggest problems and really see, okay, is this something that you're dealing with in real time? And one of the things that, just to piggyback on what you were saying, Casey, about the technology and the issues that are involved with accumulating different systems and these business units, is the thing that I keep coming back to over and over again is this idea of a hierarchy.
And when we go to these shows, it's never more apparent because there's technology all over the place. Some of our partners are there that... the software, the platforms that really make this digital experience work. But these companies, these manufacturers and distributors that we talk to, their problem is not primarily the technology or the lack of it, or even the fact that there's multiple systems.
Really, what happens underneath that technology layer is the data foundation, and what happens underneath that data foundation is what's happening in the organization in terms of culture, how do they handle change, how... It's the human side. And so that's the thing that keeps amazing me is that as technology improves and these systems are more and more capable than ever, the need to have really sharp governance and change management and process documentation, these are the human things that frankly, it has to start at the very top.
And that executive team, that executive sponsor, whoever's leading the digital channels, has to drive that culture of change and innovation. And without it, what good is technology? And frankly, what good is the data, right? Like, the data problem, it has to start with my team and my process and my ability to adapt to this increasingly complex ecosystem.
Ryan: I will say that when there's a conversation, when somebody comes up at the booth, it usually starts along one of two paths. Either, to your point, Matt, that it's a top-down initiative, it's led by the executives. So somebody's out there looking at the companies, what they offer, interviewing different people, see how they would build the roadmap.
And then sometimes, to be honest, it's a little bit sad when somebody comes up and says, "Hey, I'm the end user practitioner, and this is the struggle we have, and it's so difficult. And no matter what we say to our executives, they either don't understand it or they don't think it's a priority." And you almost feel the helplessness that those people have with what they're trying to achieve.
And whether that's, maybe in reality they weren't able to create a business case to bring it up, or maybe that change management is not hitting in the executive level and there needs to be some movement up there. But it usually follows one of those two paths, and trying to help these customers create a business case is something that we help with when need be.
But it is such an easier conversation when it's a top-led executive initiative, if you will.
Sponsor read: Everyone knows their product data needs work. The problem is figuring out where to start and how to fund it. Pivotree's data transformation pilot gives you actual proof that better product data equals more revenue. Find out how it works at data.pivotree.com/pilot. That's data.pivotree.com/pilot.
Casey: You know what is really interesting? That kind of streamlines into what I was just thinking, which is, top-down, obviously the way I think things ideally should be run because you have many problems in an organization, and then you hear these end users and what you don't think or maybe what the end users don't realize is they're living in a very, as I stated earlier, like a siloed world, right?
So their problem is the biggest problem to them. But what they may not realize is that there's 12 of them all bringing their own problems up to executive leadership. Which brings me to my main point, which is, I think that what I often hear, and I think you guys would agree with this, is that organizations are overwhelmed by so many things that they don't know where to start, right?
Like, they don't have a roadmap and a prioritization of how to handle all these problems collectively and what is most important to the business or what is bottom line going to be most effective to say, "Hey, if we go from A to B to C to D, et cetera, that's going to be the best path to make us successful as a business."
So I think that's something that we hear all the time, and I definitely heard at the show, is like, who can help lead them to the promised land, right? Like, who can help them prioritize, create the roadmap, and understand where to start and where to end? So...
Matt: Ryan can, I can tell you that right now.
Floyd: Ryan's the guy. Obviously at the booth, I was the personality hire. I think everybody knows that. And...
Ryan: Yeah, we're pretty dull without you.
Floyd: I was quite busy running our LEGO product data telephone game for most of the show. Of course, that gave me ample opportunities to eavesdrop on Matt and Ryan's conversations.
And Matt, something I heard come up in your conversations a lot was this notion for manufacturers of closing the loop. Can you talk about that? What came up and what did you have to say in response?
Matt: I mean, after the third or fourth manufacturer that I talked to who mentioned this issue, I literally laughed out loud and I said, "I'm not trying to make light of your challenge, but you are the third or fourth person who's mentioned this to me today." And yeah, it's a real challenge, right?
Because it comes back to channel management and ultimately, right, so manufacturers have been shipping product data to their channels for years and years. But more and more today, the digital shelf or what the product is represented as on a distributor website is very much a priority for manufacturers.
So they're competing with shelf space, right, with competitors, and they are going out, and so after they ship the product data, they're going out, they have teams of people who go to their top distributor websites and they're looking at their product data, and the thing that they're seeing is, whoops, I sent this product data to a industry aggregator or a data pool, and they completely stripped out my brand differentiation, right?
So now I look just like my competitor. Maybe worse, I'm missing key images or spec sheets. My marketing team spent a lot of energy into making my copy unique, but now it's like two sentences and it's got five attributes. I sent them 45 attributes. What's the deal, right? And so they're trying to go back to the distributor and say, "Hey, can I update my catalog on your website?"
Or even worse, products are being discontinued or changed completely. The manufacturer sent an updated data feed, but the distributor never took action, okay? So that's understandable. The distributor's trying desperately just to keep up with new product introduction and they're just trying to put out fires.
But the manufacturers are very concerned about what's happened to the data after it left their desk. And now that it's on the distributor's website, what are we gonna do? How are we gonna close the loop, essentially, between what's happened after I sent my product data, and how can I remediate any issues that I'm finding with my distributor channels?
And so this is a very manual process. There's a lot of literally humans going to websites and looking up products, flipping through hundreds of product detail pages. And then there's the whole issue of, okay, once I find and list all the issues or do an audit, how do I actually get my distributor to fix it?
So there's a lot of communication, and this is an area where I believe AI and automation can really streamline things and make that data transfer and closing the loop on that data easier than ever. And so we're working on some POCs now, where we're gonna use AI to help us close this loop and better streamline this channel relationship.
Floyd: That's super cool. And what a great application for AI too, right? Because you have a human looking at, building, looking over, approving that golden record, and the job is really, what is the delta here? And that's not something that you necessarily need somebody... I mean, online shopping all day is a job.
Sure, that might be fun for some things, but for a whole catalog of electrical components, maybe not quite so fascinating. Casey and Ryan, did you hear anything about this on the floor?
Ryan: Yeah. I mean, I would echo exactly what Matt said there, but I wanted to zoom out a little bit and just speak to how important these types of conferences are. Not for us to be able to sell or things like that, but look at here's four or five people all doing similar types of business that all came up to Matt and all said the exact same thing to him.
And it's important that these people have a place to go to find peers that are going through the same scenarios that they're going through, to, A, understand that they're not alone, to, B, hopefully try to find some thought leadership. And I think that speaks at the whole of why we do this.
Like, sure, we're there, our competitors are there. We're all trying to do the same thing. We're trying to help these companies get through a decision-making process that's risky, that's extremely costly, that has people within the business putting their social credibility and where they are within the company, that political credit, if you will, on the line.
And I think it just really speaks to how important these conferences are for people to have a place to go to be able to do that. And that's one of the things I really enjoy about it. Another thing I notice now is what a time we live in where we have to say whether it's AI or a human going to do the work now.
It's such a different conversation than we would've been having a few years ago, and it's neat to see it transform in that direction.
Floyd: ...does not go to conferences, so we get to go there and hang out with real human beings. Although on the other hand, AI can't give me a cold, so maybe AI wins this round, but...
Casey: Very true. That's a very valid point actually. What I would say is, kinda same vein as what both of you guys were talking about, is obviously technology is changing, right? And that to me is very interesting because we're all trying to figure out the same problems, but the problems can be addressed very differently all of a sudden than they ever have been, right?
And I think all of us are thinking simultaneously about, well, what is the best way now, right? And it creates an environment of disruption, right? And when you look at this industry, I think that things have always been done the same way, right? This is how it's done. And all of a sudden there's an opportunity to break that pattern, and people, naturally as humans, we get uncomfortable with change, right?
And I think that it's really interesting to hear these different ideas come out of like, okay, well, how can we distribute our information, the close the loop kinda conversation, differently or in a more enriched way to help me differentiate, right? We're used to having that, this is who you hand the data to, they hand it off to the next person, and this is what it needs to look like very specifically, same as A, B, and C.
And it doesn't necessarily need to be like that anymore. And it's not a matter of no one's willing to do it. It's a matter of no one knows the best way. And I think that's what we're trying to figure out, right? So to me that's really powerful, and that's a big part of getting together in these events and being able to share our different thoughts and approaches, because look, disruption is coming, for the better, I think.
It's just a matter of what that disruption's gonna look like.
Ryan: To Casey's point there real quick, sometimes the practitioners come up to us and expect a very streamlined answer, and it's not there because we have to learn so much about what they do. Sure, there's some best practice things that can be implemented that are pretty structured and pretty streamlined, if you will, but every business is different, and sometimes the bigger problem needs to be tackled before the best practice, if you will, can be implemented or... Yeah, it's important to go down that and have that discussion with them, and that's another thing that I really enjoy about these conferences as well, too.
Floyd: Nice. All right, let's close the loop on this episode with a lightning...
Casey: ...what you did there.
Floyd: Thank you. Best booth swag. Obviously us. We had the squishies and the LEGO, but other than... We don't count. We're disqualified. Favourite booth swag you saw at B2B Online Atlanta. Go.
Casey: Shout out to HawkSearch. They had the little hawks, which, A, they said they were like, "This kind of aligns with Atlanta," right? But also my kids love them. They've already named both their hawks and...
Floyd: Okay, wait. What did your kids name their hawks? 'Cause...
Casey: Do you really wanna know?
Floyd: Valley.
Ryan: I've got a good one.
Casey: So I'll tell you, this isn't gonna make a lot of sense to you guys. Their grandfather's name is Carmen, so one of them is named Diddy Carm, like Diddy Bird and Carmen. And the other one's named Baby Carm. So that is the name of the two hawks. Yes.
Ryan: Long as it's not after P. Diddy, we're all right.
Casey: Yeah, we're good.
Floyd: That would be weird.
Ryan: I'll just give you the top one. My oldest named her HawkSearch stuffy Soar, which I...
Casey: That's nice. Good, yeah.
Floyd: Nice.
Ryan: And then as far as the best, I'm gonna go off the table here and say the football touchdown thing that we commandeered and brought over.
Floyd: That we stole.
Casey: Yeah, we did steal it, yeah. No one was using it.
Ryan: Nobody was using it until we brought it over.
So I think that was great. It was a little target practice with some mini footballs that you could throw to get points. So we brought that over to the booth for some people to have fun 'cause nobody was using it where it was.
Matt: I love it. This is part of why I had so much fun on this event because, I mean, we were stealing the touchdown game. We stole a booth next to us where we had meetings.
Casey: Everything except for the couches from the networking location.
Matt: Which you wanted to do, but I told you that's crossing a line.
Casey: Gotta blow up my spot here, huh?
Matt: But I just wanna say, shout out to Floyd.
Yes, first time on the ground, and boy, we had a great booth experience. Our giveaways were top-notch. People loved the LEGO sets. They loved the game. Our squishies dominated the show by far. You gotta get a squishy. Guys, if you're listeners and you want a squishy, you just let us know.
Drop us a comment on LinkedIn and we'll get you a Pivotree...
Floyd: ...you one.
Matt: Yeah, for sure.
Floyd: All right, Matt with the unauthorized giveaway. No, I love it. And also I have one of our Pivotree squishies, so just a little bonus content for those of you who are watching on YouTube. Yeah, write us. We'll send you one. Okay. I had a lot of fun at the event. I had a lot of fun doing this episode, and I hope that this has been useful for people because sometimes you're thinking about your events for next year, wondering what really goes on there, who's attending, is it valuable?
So if you didn't go this year, we saved you a few bucks, and now you know. Next year it's gonna be the place to be, and we'll see you there. Thank you, Ryan. Thank you, Matt. Thank you, Casey, and I will see you on the road again soon, I hope.
Ryan: It was a pleasure.
Matt: See you guys. Peace.
Announcer: Thanks for tuning in to this episode of Data vs. Commerce. New episodes drop weekly. So if you're responsible for any part of how products get from a database to a doorstep, subscribe now on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen.
Subscribe today.
If you're responsible for any part of how products get from a database to a doorstep, this is your show. New episodes drop weekly.